What to Consider When You Evaluate Feature Requests

In the world of product development, feature requests are a common occurrence. They come from various sources, ranging from customers to internal stakeholders. As a product manager or developer, it's crucial to evaluate these requests carefully to ensure that you are making informed decisions about what features to prioritize and implement. In this article, we will explore what factors you should consider when evaluating feature requests.

Understanding the Importance of Evaluating Feature Requests

Before diving into the evaluation process, it's essential to understand why it matters. Evaluating feature requests allows you to gauge their potential impact on your product and make informed decisions. By considering various factors, you can prioritize feature requests effectively and allocate resources accordingly.

One key aspect of evaluating feature requests is assessing their alignment with your product roadmap. Understanding how a requested feature fits into your long-term vision for the product can help you determine its importance. It's crucial to consider whether the feature aligns with your overall business goals and strategy. Additionally, evaluating the potential user impact of a feature request is vital. Analyzing how many users would benefit from the proposed feature and how it aligns with user needs can provide valuable insights into its priority level.

Furthermore, evaluating feature requests involves assessing technical feasibility and complexity. Understanding the resources, time, and effort required to implement a feature is essential for making realistic decisions. It's important to consider how a new feature would integrate with existing functionalities and whether it would require significant changes to the underlying infrastructure. By evaluating these aspects thoroughly, you can ensure that the features you prioritize are not only beneficial to users but also feasible to implement within your product development timeline.

What Are Feature Requests? Defining the Basics

Feature requests are suggestions or ideas from users or stakeholders about new features or improvements they would like to see in a product. These requests can come in various forms, including direct feedback, user surveys, or support tickets. Understanding the basics of feature requests is the first step in evaluating them effectively.

When it comes to handling feature requests, it's essential for product teams to prioritize them based on various factors such as alignment with the product roadmap, impact on user experience, and feasibility of implementation. Prioritization helps ensure that valuable feedback is not lost in the sea of requests and that resources are allocated efficiently to address the most critical needs of the users.

Moreover, feature requests play a crucial role in shaping the future direction of a product. By analyzing common themes and patterns in the requests received, product managers can gain valuable insights into user preferences and pain points. This data-driven approach not only helps in making informed decisions about which features to prioritize but also fosters a sense of community and collaboration between the product team and its users.

When Should You Prioritize Feature Requests in Product Development?

Not all feature requests are created equal. Some may have a more significant impact on your product's success than others. It's essential to prioritize feature requests based on their potential value, alignment with your product strategy, and overall feasibility. In this section, we will explore when and how to prioritize feature requests.

One crucial factor to consider when prioritizing feature requests is customer feedback. Understanding what your users want and need can help you determine which features are most important to them. Conducting surveys, analyzing support tickets, and monitoring social media can provide valuable insights into customer preferences. By listening to your users, you can prioritize feature requests that align with their expectations and improve their overall experience with your product.

Another key consideration in prioritizing feature requests is the impact on your development team. Evaluating the complexity and resources required for each feature can help you allocate your team's time and effort effectively. It's essential to balance short-term wins with long-term investments to ensure sustainable product development. By considering both customer feedback and development resources, you can make informed decisions about which feature requests to prioritize.

What Criteria to Use When Evaluating Feature Requests

When faced with several feature requests, it can be challenging to make sense of them all. To streamline the evaluation process, it's helpful to establish criteria for assessing feature requests. These criteria may include factors such as user demand, market trends, technical feasibility, and potential business impact.

One crucial aspect to consider when evaluating feature requests is user demand. Understanding the needs and preferences of your user base is essential for prioritizing which features to develop. Conducting user surveys, analyzing customer feedback, and monitoring support requests can provide valuable insights into what features are most desired by your users.

Market trends also play a significant role in determining which feature requests to prioritize. Keeping an eye on industry trends, competitor offerings, and emerging technologies can help you identify opportunities to stay ahead of the curve and meet the evolving needs of your target market.

Read more on the same topic here:

How to Gather and Organize Feature Requests for Evaluation

Before you can evaluate feature requests, you need a systematic way to collect and organize them. In this section, we will discuss how to gather feature requests effectively and create a process that ensures all requests are considered and evaluated properly.

One effective method for gathering feature requests is to create a dedicated channel or platform where users can submit their ideas and suggestions. This can be a simple online form on your website, a designated email address, or a community forum where users can discuss and upvote the features they would like to see. By providing a centralized location for submitting requests, you can streamline the process and ensure that no valuable suggestions fall through the cracks.

Additionally, it can be beneficial to categorize feature requests based on their impact and feasibility. Prioritizing requests that align with your product roadmap and have the potential to add significant value to your users can help you focus on the most important enhancements. By evaluating the effort required to implement each feature request, you can also assess the feasibility of turning these ideas into reality within a reasonable timeframe. This strategic approach can help you make informed decisions and allocate resources effectively to deliver the most impactful features to your users.

What Tools Can Aid in the Evaluation of Feature Requests?

Technology can play a valuable role in simplifying and streamlining the feature request evaluation process. There are numerous tools available that can help you manage and prioritize feature requests, track their status, and facilitate collaboration with your team. In this section, we will explore some popular tools and evaluate their benefits.

Section Image

One widely used tool for evaluating feature requests is product management software. These platforms offer a centralized location to collect, organize, and analyze incoming feature requests. Product managers can use these tools to categorize requests based on factors such as impact, feasibility, and alignment with the company's strategic goals. By leveraging product management software, teams can make data-driven decisions when evaluating which features to prioritize for development.

Another valuable tool in the evaluation process is customer feedback analytics software. This type of tool allows companies to gather and analyze feedback from various sources, such as surveys, reviews, and social media. By aggregating and analyzing customer feedback, organizations can identify recurring themes and pain points, which can inform the prioritization of feature requests. Additionally, customer feedback analytics software can provide insights into user preferences and behaviors, helping teams make informed decisions about which features will have the most significant impact on user satisfaction.

When to Say Yes: Identifying High-Impact Feature Requests

Not all feature requests are created equal. Some have the potential to greatly impact your product's success. Identifying high-impact feature requests is crucial to ensure that you are investing resources wisely. This section will provide insights into how to recognize high-impact feature requests and what factors to consider when making this determination.

One key factor to consider when evaluating the impact of a feature request is the size of the user base that will benefit from it. A feature that addresses a common pain point for a large portion of your users is more likely to have a significant impact on user satisfaction and retention. Additionally, features that align with your product's core value proposition or unique selling points are more likely to drive user engagement and differentiate your product from competitors.

Another important consideration is the potential for a feature to open up new opportunities for revenue generation. High-impact feature requests may introduce new monetization strategies, such as premium subscriptions, in-app purchases, or partnerships with third-party services. By prioritizing features that have the potential to increase revenue streams, you can ensure the long-term sustainability and growth of your product.

What to Do With Low-Priority Feature Requests

While high-impact feature requests undoubtedly deserve attention, what about the low-priority ones? What should you do with requests that may not align with your product strategy or have minimal user demand? In this section, we will discuss strategies for handling low-priority feature requests without dismissing them outright.

One approach to consider when dealing with low-priority feature requests is to create a backlog specifically for these types of requests. By maintaining a separate backlog, you can keep track of these ideas without cluttering your main development pipeline. This allows you to revisit these requests at a later time when resources become available or when there is a shift in priorities.

Another strategy is to engage with the users who submitted these low-priority requests. By opening a dialogue with them, you can gain a deeper understanding of their needs and motivations. This can provide valuable insights that may lead to innovative solutions or help you uncover hidden opportunities that align with your product vision. Remember, even low-priority requests can sometimes hold the key to unlocking new possibilities for your product.

How to Communicate Decisions on Feature Requests to Stakeholders

Transparent communication is crucial when it comes to feature requests. As a product manager or developer, it's essential to articulate your decisions and provide rationale to stakeholders. In this section, we will explore best practices for effectively communicating decisions on feature requests and maintaining a collaborative relationship with all parties involved.

Section Image

One key aspect of communicating decisions on feature requests is setting clear expectations from the outset. By establishing a transparent process for how feature requests will be evaluated and decided upon, stakeholders can have a better understanding of the timeline and criteria involved. This can help manage expectations and reduce potential misunderstandings or frustrations down the line.

Furthermore, it's important to involve stakeholders in the decision-making process whenever possible. By seeking input and feedback from relevant parties early on, you can ensure that their perspectives are taken into account and that decisions are made with a comprehensive understanding of the implications. This collaborative approach not only fosters a sense of ownership and buy-in from stakeholders but also leads to more informed and well-rounded decisions.

Best Practices for Evaluating Feature Requests Effectively

At the end of the day, evaluating feature requests is a continuous learning process. It requires a thoughtful approach and an understanding of your product's goals and priorities. In this section, we will discuss some best practices to keep in mind as you evaluate feature requests, ensuring that you make informed decisions that benefit your product and its users.

Section Image

By considering the importance of evaluating feature requests, understanding the basics, establishing criteria, and utilizing the right tools, you can streamline the evaluation process. Remember to communicate decisions effectively to stakeholders and adopt best practices throughout. Evaluating feature requests is a constant journey that can help you shape your product's future and ensure its success.

One key aspect to consider when evaluating feature requests is the impact on user experience. It's crucial to assess how a new feature will enhance or potentially disrupt the user journey. Conducting user testing and gathering feedback can provide valuable insights into how users interact with your product and what improvements they desire. By prioritizing features that align with user needs and preferences, you can create a more user-centric product that fosters loyalty and satisfaction.

Furthermore, when evaluating feature requests, it's essential to take into account the technical feasibility and resource implications. Assessing whether a proposed feature aligns with your product's architecture and development capabilities is vital to avoid potential roadblocks and ensure timely delivery. Collaborating closely with your engineering team and project managers can help in estimating the effort required for implementation and balancing it against other priorities on the product roadmap.

Read more on the same topic here:

Last Updated:

Kareem Mayan

Kareem is a co-founder at Savio. He's been prioritizing customer feedback professionally since 2001. He likes tea and tea snacks, and dislikes refraining from eating lots of tea snacks.

Want more articles like this?

Product Leaders from Slack, Zapier, and Appcues read our newsletter to delight customers, lower churn, and grow revenue.

Prioritize high-value Feature Requests

Centralize customer feedback from HubSpot, Intercom, and Slack.

Prioritize high-value features sorted by churned revenue or MRR.

Close the loop for Sales and CS by automating status updates from JIRA.

Learn more


Use HubSpot CRM? Collect and Prioritize Feature Requests

Get a central hub of customer feedback sorted by HubSpot attributes like churn or MRR.